The hardest part of starting a songwriting journal isn't the writing. It's not knowing what "done" looks like. How messy is too messy? How polished should the final version be? What do actual filled-in pages look like?
Here are 5 songs developed over 3 months in the same journal. Some are finished. Some are still fragments. The pages show different approaches. lyrics-first, melody-first, multiple revision sessions, and abandoned ideas that might come back.
The crossed-out words tell the story. "Midnight" became "late night" became "sleepless." Each version scratched out but still visible. That's not mess (that's process.)
What You'll Notice
Across these 5 songs, patterns emerge:
- Not every page is finished. Song #2 is just brainstorming. That's fine. Some ideas need more time.
- Revision is visible. Crossed-out words, arrows, alternate versions scribbled in margins. The pages show the work.
- The brainstorming pages get used differently. Word clusters for one song. Full sentences for another. Rhyme lists for a third.
- The staff page is optional. Some songs use it heavily. Others barely touch it.
The journal used here is the Lyrics Remembered journal, with its 4-page format: brainstorming, staff, and lyrics. But the principles apply to any consistent system.
Song #1: "Red Light District" (Fully Developed)
Started: January 8
Finished: January 22
Sessions: 4
This one came together fast. The opening line appeared almost complete, and the rest followed.
[PHOTO: Page 1 brainstorming spread showing mood marked as "restless, urban, 2am energy" and tempo noted as "mid-tempo, driving." Dot-grid area filled with word clusters: "neon," "humming," "static," "brake lights," "waiting," "exhaust." Arrows connect related words. Corner has a note: "Voice memo 1/8 - chorus melody."]
The brainstorming page has 27 rhyme options grouped by sound. "Night/light/fight/sight" in one cluster. "Alone/phone/unknown/tone" in another. Only 4 made the final lyrics.
[PHOTO: Page 2 music staff showing a simple melody notation across two staves, chord symbols written above (Am - F - C - G), with a note at the bottom: "Chorus sits higher. Verse stays in lower range."]
[PHOTO: Pages 3-4 lyrics section showing Verse 1, Chorus, Verse 2, and Bridge all filled in with clean handwriting. A few words are crossed out with replacements written above. The final Chorus section has "repeat 2x, ad-lib last time" written in the margin.]
This is what a completed entry looks like. Four pages, all used. The song moved from brainstorm to finished draft in two weeks across four writing sessions.
Song #2: "Something About Leaving" (Brainstorm Only)
Started: January 29
Status: In progress
Some ideas aren't ready. This one has energy but no structure yet.
[PHOTO: Page 1 brainstorming page heavily filled with phrases, not word clusters. "Why does every exit feel like drowning" and "The airport bar where we said nothing" and "You kissed me like you were already gone." Mood box says "melancholic but not slow." Tempo box is blank.]
The lyrics pages are empty. The staff page has a few notes about chord voicings but no melody.
This is normal. Not every song moves forward on schedule. The brainstorming page preserves the emotional core so when the song is ready to develop, the raw material is there.
[PHOTO: Pages 3-4 showing empty lyrics sections with pre-printed Verse/Chorus/Bridge headers, demonstrating what "in progress" looks like (brainstorming done, drafting not started.])
Song #3: "Sleepless" (Multiple Sessions, Heavy Revision)
Started: February 3
Finished: March 14
Sessions: 7
This one fought back. The first version of the chorus got scrapped entirely after session 4. The final version came together 6 weeks after the first draft.
[PHOTO: Page 1 brainstorming with visible layers of different ink colors showing multiple sessions. Original word cluster around "insomnia" expanded to include "3am thoughts," "ceiling fan," "phone glow," "her side of the bed cold." Later additions in different pen: "counting hours," "waiting for exhaustion."]
[PHOTO: Pages 3-4 showing heavy revision. Verse 1 has two lines completely crossed out with new lines written between them. The Chorus section shows the original lyrics scratched out entirely with "SEE PAGE 1 - NEW VERSION" written and an arrow pointing left. The margin has the date "3/14" next to the final draft.]
Song #3 sat untouched for 6 weeks before the bridge finally clicked. The journal preserved all the earlier work, so returning after a month and a half didn't mean starting over.
Song #4: "Hum" (Melody-First)
Started: February 18
Finished: February 25
Sessions: 3
Most songs start with words. This one started with a melody.
[PHOTO: Page 2 music staff page filled with notation. a complete verse melody written out, chord symbols above (Dm - Bb - F - C), and rhythm marks showing where the emphasis falls. A note says "Lyrics need to match the triplet feel in bar 3."]
[PHOTO: Page 1 brainstorming page that's mostly empty except for the mood ("warm, nostalgic, Sunday morning") and a list of syllable counts: "7-7-8-7 for verse, 6-6-10 for chorus." The words came after the melody was locked.]
The lyrics pages show writing that fits the pre-existing melody. Syllable counts are marked in the margins. Lines that didn't fit the rhythm are crossed out with alternatives.
[PHOTO: Pages 3-4 lyrics section with margin notes like "3 syllables here" and "hold on 'you'" showing how the words were fitted to the melody.]
This is what melody-first writing looks like in a journal. The staff page leads. Everything else follows.
Song #5: "Backroads" (Lyrics-First, Minimal Notation)
Started: March 2
Finished: March 10
Sessions: 2
Some songs don't need notation. This one was words from the start.
[PHOTO: Page 1 brainstorming page covered in full sentences, not word clusters. "Gravel under tires," "The town we swore we'd leave," "Corn taller than the car," "That gas station where nothing ever changed." Mood box: "nostalgic but not sad." Tempo box: "slow, acoustic."]
[PHOTO: Page 2 staff page nearly empty. just a note at the top: "Am-G-C. Simple. Don't overcomplicate."]
The lyrics pages are full. Two verses, chorus, bridge. all drafted in two sessions. Minimal revisions. Sometimes a song just arrives.
[PHOTO: Pages 3-4 fully filled with clean handwriting, minimal cross-outs, showing a song that came together quickly.]
What 3 Months Reveals
After 5 songs (and a few more not shown), the journal becomes a record of process:
Different songs need different timelines. Song #1 took two weeks. Song #3 took six. Both are valid.
Brainstorming pages show how you think. Word clusters for some songs. Sentences for others. The dot-grid accommodates both.
The staff page is there when you need it. Used heavily for melody-first writing. Nearly empty for lyrics-first. Optional, not required.
Revision is part of the process. Crossed-out words aren't failure. They're evidence that you pushed past the first draft.
For prompts to fill your own brainstorming pages, see our 75 songwriting prompts. For a complete approach to using this system, read our songwriting journal guide.
The Lyrics Remembered journal holds 30 songs with this 4-page format. room for a substantial body of work from brainstorm to finished lyrics.
[PHOTO: Final spread showing the journal lying open to display the 4-page format across two entries, with the cover visible at the edge, demonstrating the overall look of a partially-filled journal.]
Frequently Asked Questions
How long does it take to fill a page during a writing session?
A brainstorming page might take 15-30 minutes. Lyrics pages vary. a verse can take 10 minutes or an hour depending on how the writing flows. There's no standard pace.
Should every page be this detailed?
No. Some songs get minimal brainstorming. Some skip the staff page entirely. Use what the song needs. The format accommodates both sparse and detailed entries.
What if my handwriting is messy?
So is everyone's. These pages show crossed-out words, arrows, and cramped margin notes. Legibility matters; neatness doesn't. You're the primary reader.
How do I know when a song is "finished"?
When you've drafted all sections and stopped making changes. Some songs reach that point quickly. Others sit in revision for weeks. The journal holds both.
Is it okay to leave songs unfinished?
Yes. Song #2 in this article is still just brainstorming. It might become something in 6 months, or it might not. The journal preserves the work so you can return to it.
What do you do with pages that didn't work out?
Leave them. They're part of the record. Sometimes a line from a failed song becomes the hook for a better one. Don't tear out pages (let the failures stay.)
Share: